A new vigilante killer arises, targeting old, retired super-villains for extermination, with an alarming success rate! Meanwhile, a new super-villain begins humiliating members of the Justice Society of America, one by one! Can the JSA discover the truth about the Sunset Killer and stop the crime spree of Black Nemesis before their reputation is completely ruined? Guest starring Infinity Inc!
Two criminal masterminds, specialists in fear and psychology, enact an evil plot to destroy Batman once and for all! The only problem is that Batman and Robin are away from Gotham City on a case. Can a handful of non-powered Justice Society of America members — the Atom, Doctor Mid-Nite, Mister Terrific, and Wildcat — defeat a gathering of some of the most dangerous Bat-foes?